P · 15 seasons · 1910 – 1925 · B/T: R/L
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1910 | CIN | 12 | -2.43 | #559 | #96,505 |
| 1911 | CIN | 6 | -2.26 | #539 | #83,789 |
| 1912 | CIN | 50 | -2.93 | #693 | #107,902 |
| 1913★ | CIN | 23 | -1.71 | #302 | #44,934 |
| 1914 | CIN | 41 | -2.95 | #797 | #108,126 |
| 1915 | CIN | 45 | -2.24 | #437 | #81,733 |
| 1916 | NY1 | 38 | -3.32 | #648 | #110,302 |
| 1917 | NY1 | 35 | -2.89 | #560 | #107,442 |
| 1918 | NY1 | 3 | -2.35 | #483 | #92,114 |
| 1919 | NY1 | 35 | -1.85 | #288 | #47,496 |
| 1920 | NY1 | 33 | -3.03 | #748 | #108,761 |
| 1921 | NY1 | 18 | -2.57 | #678 | #101,834 |
| 1923 | CIN | 33 | -1.98 | #413 | #51,405 |
| 1924 | CIN | 32 | -2.23 | #480 | #80,233 |
| 1925 | CIN | 33 | -2.77 | #764 | #105,868 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1910 | CIN | 12 | -3.41 | #237 | #47,847 |
| 1911 | CIN | 6 | -0.78 | #101 | #22,127 |
| 1912 | CIN | 50 | 5.30 | #27 | #5,032 |
| 1913 | CIN | 23 | -0.16 | #84 | #19,144 |
| 1914 | CIN | 41 | 4.49 | #44 | #6,263 |
| 1915 | CIN | 45 | 3.84 | #56 | #7,418 |
| 1916 | NY1 | 38 | 4.71 | #30 | #5,925 |
| 1917 | NY1 | 35 | 4.97 | #26 | #5,501 |
| 1918 | NY1 | 3 | -0.82 | #103 | #22,335 |
| 1919★ | NY1 | 35 | 6.53 | #21 | #3,553 |
| 1920 | NY1 | 33 | 3.60 | #49 | #7,870 |
| 1921 | NY1 | 18 | 0.21 | #106 | #17,502 |
| 1923 | CIN | 33 | 4.10 | #49 | #6,939 |
| 1924 | CIN | 32 | 4.98 | #44 | #5,488 |
| 1925 | CIN | 33 | 1.71 | #89 | #12,408 |
★ Best season by Z