P · 8 seasons · 1928 – 1948 · B/T: R/R
Earl Caldwell ranks 1st of 0 pitchers by career roto value, one of the highest totals the site records. His best year was 1946: +11.7 roto value, 8th that season and 614th of 51,303 player-seasons on record. He banked roto value in saves (+10.9) and gave it back in WHIP (-2.7) and ERA (-2.4).
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1928 | PHI | 5 | -2.44 | #612 | #97,300 |
| 1935 | SLA | 6 | -2.44 | #535 | #97,048 |
| 1936 | SLA | 41 | -2.28 | #474 | #85,627 |
| 1937 | SLA | 9 | -2.07 | #512 | #60,387 |
| 1945★ | CWS | 27 | -1.91 | #455 | #48,955 |
| 1946 | CWS | 39 | -2.03 | #642 | #55,083 |
| 1947 | CWS | 40 | -2.32 | #728 | #89,506 |
| 1948 | CWS | 33 | -2.14 | #647 | #70,644 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1928 | PHI | 5 | -3.07 | #294 | #45,801 |
| 1935 | SLA | 6 | -1.45 | #144 | #26,242 |
| 1936 | SLA | 41 | -2.49 | #207 | #39,057 |
| 1937 | SLA | 9 | -3.01 | #306 | #45,342 |
| 1945 | CWS | 27 | 3.08 | #58 | #8,896 |
| 1946★ | CWS | 39 | 11.66 | #8 | #614 |
| 1947 | CWS | 40 | 2.08 | #76 | #11,360 |
| 1948 | CWS | 33 | -2.72 | #293 | #42,288 |
★ Best season by Z