P · 14 seasons · 1917 – 1930 · B/T: R/R
Few careers score higher: Hal Carlson sits 1st of 0 pitchers all-time in roto value, built over 14 seasons. 1926 was the high-water mark, worth +6.5, 25th that season and 3634th of 51,303 player-seasons on record. His profile is all upside: wins (+7.2), strikeouts (+4.1) and WHIP (+1.9), and nothing on the debit side.
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1917 | PIT | 34 | -2.96 | #569 | #108,230 |
| 1918 | PIT | 3 | -2.34 | #478 | #91,278 |
| 1919 | PIT | 22 | -2.56 | #527 | #101,645 |
| 1920 | PIT | 39 | -1.93 | #393 | #49,335 |
| 1921 | PIT | 31 | -2.13 | #408 | #68,832 |
| 1922 | PIT | 39 | -1.52 | #320 | #42,251 |
| 1923 | PIT | 4 | -2.51 | #723 | #99,965 |
| 1924★ | PHI | 39 | -1.35 | #347 | #40,259 |
| 1925 | PHI | 38 | -2.42 | #518 | #96,061 |
| 1926 | PHI | 38 | -1.85 | #394 | #47,448 |
| 1927 | CHC | 39 | -2.64 | #736 | #103,591 |
| 1928 | CHC | 20 | -2.35 | #510 | #92,276 |
| 1929 | CHC | 31 | -2.20 | #444 | #77,501 |
| 1930 | CHC | 8 | -2.36 | #484 | #92,775 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1917 | PIT | 34 | 0.80 | #71 | #15,318 |
| 1918 | PIT | 3 | -2.22 | #179 | #34,872 |
| 1919 | PIT | 22 | 2.81 | #48 | #9,501 |
| 1920 | PIT | 39 | 4.98 | #37 | #5,500 |
| 1921 | PIT | 31 | 2.92 | #57 | #9,251 |
| 1922 | PIT | 39 | -1.09 | #132 | #23,883 |
| 1923 | PIT | 4 | -2.31 | #222 | #36,197 |
| 1924 | PHI | 38 | -0.09 | #124 | #18,851 |
| 1925 | PHI | 35 | 3.72 | #53 | #7,654 |
| 1926★ | PHI | 35 | 6.46 | #25 | #3,634 |
| 1927 | CHC | 38 | 4.21 | #49 | #6,750 |
| 1928 | CHC | 20 | 0.33 | #107 | #17,040 |
| 1929 | CHC | 31 | 1.61 | #85 | #12,719 |
| 1930 | CHC | 8 | -1.76 | #161 | #28,847 |
★ Best season by Z