P · 14 seasons · 1912 – 1928 · B/T: R/R
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1912 | PHA | 5 | -2.25 | #577 | #82,130 |
| 1916 | CLE | 45 | -1.76 | #290 | #45,721 |
| 1917 | CLE | 46 | -3.33 | #585 | #110,321 |
| 1918 | CLE | 38 | -2.72 | #578 | #105,123 |
| 1919 | CLE | 43 | -2.14 | #333 | #71,153 |
| 1920★ | CLE | 41 | -1.40 | #284 | #40,745 |
| 1921 | CLE | 43 | -3.20 | #742 | #109,786 |
| 1922 | CLE | 35 | -3.83 | #771 | #111,200 |
| 1923 | CLE | 33 | -3.43 | #832 | #110,595 |
| 1924 | CLE | 37 | -3.55 | #866 | #110,845 |
| 1925 | WS1 | 32 | -3.60 | #844 | #110,987 |
| 1926 | WS1 | 36 | -2.67 | #739 | #104,204 |
| 1927 | WS1 | 5 | -2.30 | #493 | #87,933 |
| 1928 | NYY | 12 | -2.75 | #741 | #105,609 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1912 | PHA | 5 | -1.19 | #107 | #24,537 |
| 1916 | CLE | 45 | 1.26 | #65 | #13,783 |
| 1917 | CLE | 45 | 12.30 | #5 | #477 |
| 1918 | CLE | 38 | 12.41 | #5 | #468 |
| 1919 | CLE | 43 | 11.34 | #7 | #700 |
| 1920★ | CLE | 41 | 13.51 | #4 | #310 |
| 1921 | CLE | 43 | 8.69 | #14 | #1,793 |
| 1922 | CLE | 35 | 9.36 | #12 | #1,433 |
| 1923 | CLE | 33 | 7.59 | #23 | #2,562 |
| 1924 | CLE | 37 | 1.73 | #90 | #12,363 |
| 1925 | WS1 | 32 | 8.58 | #14 | #1,861 |
| 1926 | WS1 | 36 | 4.26 | #53 | #6,652 |
| 1927 | WS1 | 5 | -1.77 | #176 | #28,885 |
| 1928 | NYY | 12 | -2.55 | #241 | #39,787 |
★ Best season by Z