P · 12 seasons · 1948 – 1959 · B/T: R/R
Carl Erskine ranks 637th of 11,481 pitchers by career roto value, accumulated over 12 seasons from 1948 to 1959 (10.2 wins and 81.8 strikeouts per season). 1953 was the high-water mark, worth +9.5, 7th that season and 1369th of 51,303 player-seasons on record. His profile is all upside: strikeouts (+10.9), wins (+10.5) and WHIP (+5.6), and nothing on the debit side.
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1948 | BRO | 17 | -2.45 | #774 | #97,471 |
| 1949 | BRO | 22 | -2.72 | #483 | #105,205 |
| 1950 | BRO | 22 | -2.31 | #292 | #88,698 |
| 1951 | BRO | 46 | -2.91 | #518 | #107,723 |
| 1952 | BRO | 34 | -2.76 | #512 | #105,793 |
| 1953 | BRO | 43 | -2.13 | #270 | #68,920 |
| 1954 | BRO | 39 | -2.92 | #517 | #107,849 |
| 1955★ | BRO | 42 | -1.70 | #235 | #44,748 |
| 1956 | BRO | 32 | -3.28 | #547 | #110,193 |
| 1957 | BRO | 21 | -2.60 | #497 | #102,703 |
| 1958 | LAD | 32 | -2.90 | #561 | #107,600 |
| 1959 | LAD | 10 | -2.44 | #479 | #96,894 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1948 | BRO | 17 | 0.71 | #107 | #15,646 |
| 1949 | BRO | 22 | -0.37 | #83 | #20,157 |
| 1950 | BRO | 22 | 0.42 | #80 | #16,726 |
| 1951 | BRO | 46 | 2.86 | #47 | #9,396 |
| 1952 | BRO | 33 | 7.86 | #14 | #2,369 |
| 1953★ | BRO | 39 | 9.50 | #7 | #1,369 |
| 1954 | BRO | 38 | 5.89 | #21 | #4,243 |
| 1955 | BRO | 31 | 3.72 | #43 | #7,645 |
| 1956 | BRO | 31 | 1.88 | #60 | #11,928 |
| 1957 | BRO | 15 | -0.39 | #105 | #20,233 |
| 1958 | LAD | 31 | -2.95 | #201 | #44,701 |
| 1959 | LAD | 10 | -3.51 | #226 | #48,481 |
★ Best season by Z