P · 12 seasons · 1903 – 1917 · B/T: R/R
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1903 | PIT | 10 | -2.75 | #303 | #105,541 |
| 1905 | WS1 | 12 | -2.79 | #360 | #106,185 |
| 1906★ | WS1 | 40 | -1.46 | #203 | #41,489 |
| 1907 | WS1 | 33 | -2.96 | #455 | #108,190 |
| 1908 | WS1 | 25 | -2.55 | #360 | #101,185 |
| 1909 | CLE | 24 | -2.51 | #527 | #99,946 |
| 1910 | CLE | 37 | -2.30 | #484 | #87,941 |
| 1911 | CLE | 16 | -2.15 | #435 | #71,401 |
| 1913 | CLE | 39 | -3.08 | #678 | #109,097 |
| 1914 | IND | 49 | -2.90 | #784 | #107,626 |
| 1915 | NEW | 32 | -3.77 | #822 | #111,165 |
| 1917 | PHA | 15 | -2.50 | #487 | #99,671 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1903 | PIT | 10 | -2.99 | #132 | #45,002 |
| 1905 | WS1 | 12 | -1.92 | #96 | #30,563 |
| 1906 | WS1 | 40 | 2.21 | #45 | #10,960 |
| 1907 | WS1 | 32 | 2.20 | #42 | #11,004 |
| 1908 | WS1 | 25 | -0.81 | #78 | #22,332 |
| 1909 | CLE | 24 | 1.82 | #55 | #12,088 |
| 1910 | CLE | 37 | 2.64 | #45 | #9,869 |
| 1911 | CLE | 15 | 1.10 | #62 | #14,287 |
| 1913 | CLE | 39 | 8.53 | #13 | #1,883 |
| 1914★ | IND | 49 | 12.62 | #5 | #437 |
| 1915 | NEW | 32 | 2.40 | #68 | #10,490 |
| 1917 | PHA | 15 | -2.66 | #166 | #41,328 |
★ Best season by Z