P · 12 seasons · 1901 – 1914 · B/T: R/R
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1901★ | CWS | 35 | -0.72 | #136 | #34,865 |
| 1902 | CWS | 35 | -2.48 | #210 | #98,650 |
| 1903 | NYY | 25 | -2.25 | #201 | #81,978 |
| 1904 | NYY | 16 | -3.26 | #355 | #110,057 |
| 1905 | NYY | 26 | -2.50 | #264 | #99,545 |
| 1906 | NYY | 17 | -2.72 | #441 | #105,144 |
| 1907 | NYY | 5 | -2.58 | #354 | #102,098 |
| 1909 | CIN | 1 | -2.35 | #441 | #92,173 |
| 1910 | CIN | 1 | -2.20 | #389 | #77,224 |
| 1912 | WS1 | 1 | -2.18 | #503 | #75,602 |
| 1913 | WS1 | 1 | -2.00 | #368 | #52,086 |
| 1914 | WS1 | 1 | -2.32 | #488 | #89,328 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1901★ | CWS | 35 | 6.37 | #13 | #3,733 |
| 1902 | CWS | 28 | -1.09 | #68 | #23,879 |
| 1903 | NYY | 25 | 2.58 | #33 | #10,025 |
| 1904 | NYY | 16 | -0.89 | #66 | #22,729 |
| 1905 | NYY | 25 | 2.71 | #32 | #9,726 |
| 1906 | NYY | 17 | -0.10 | #66 | #18,878 |
| 1907 | NYY | 4 | -3.43 | #163 | #47,929 |
| 1909 | CIN | 1 | -2.63 | #187 | #40,970 |
| 1912 | WS1 | 1 | -1.93 | #158 | #30,623 |
| 1913 | WS1 | 1 | -2.00 | #155 | #31,566 |
| 1914 | WS1 | 1 | -1.77 | #156 | #28,880 |
★ Best season by Z