P · 17 seasons · 1926 – 1943 · B/T: R/R
Danny MacFayden put together 17 seasons from 1926 to 1943 and ranks 671st of 11,481 pitchers all-time in roto value (7.8 wins and 46.9 strikeouts per season). His best year was 1936: +9.3 roto value, 10th that season and 1469th of 51,303 player-seasons on record. The value came from wins (+9.1), ERA (+8.0) and strikeouts (+6.4), with no category working against him.
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1926 | BOS | 3 | -2.40 | #547 | #94,959 |
| 1927★ | BOS | 37 | -1.65 | #361 | #44,091 |
| 1928 | BOS | 35 | -3.00 | #782 | #108,561 |
| 1929 | BOS | 32 | -2.93 | #755 | #107,956 |
| 1930 | BOS | 36 | -3.14 | #726 | #109,527 |
| 1931 | BOS | 35 | -3.33 | #708 | #110,379 |
| 1932 | NYY | 29 | -3.13 | #867 | #109,474 |
| 1933 | NYY | 25 | -3.11 | #656 | #109,333 |
| 1934 | NYY | 22 | -2.70 | #665 | #104,835 |
| 1935 | BSN | 35 | -3.17 | #675 | #109,711 |
| 1936 | BSN | 37 | -3.67 | #671 | #111,183 |
| 1937 | BSN | 32 | -2.72 | #807 | #105,153 |
| 1938 | BSN | 29 | -3.57 | #830 | #111,054 |
| 1939 | BSN | 33 | -2.50 | #740 | #99,694 |
| 1940 | PIT | 35 | -2.32 | #691 | #89,519 |
| 1941 | WS1 | 5 | -2.09 | #507 | #63,489 |
| 1943 | BSN | 10 | -2.09 | #558 | #63,661 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1926 | BOS | 3 | -2.31 | #223 | #36,243 |
| 1927 | BOS | 34 | 0.53 | #102 | #16,285 |
| 1928 | BOS | 33 | -0.76 | #127 | #22,032 |
| 1929 | BOS | 32 | 3.99 | #51 | #7,137 |
| 1930 | BOS | 36 | 4.83 | #31 | #5,714 |
| 1931 | BOS | 35 | 2.10 | #58 | #11,288 |
| 1932 | NYY | 29 | 0.42 | #112 | #16,708 |
| 1933 | NYY | 25 | -4.09 | #251 | #50,014 |
| 1934 | NYY | 22 | -0.78 | #116 | #22,139 |
| 1935 | BSN | 35 | -1.15 | #138 | #24,286 |
| 1936★ | BSN | 37 | 9.31 | #10 | #1,469 |
| 1937 | BSN | 32 | 7.68 | #18 | #2,501 |
| 1938 | BSN | 29 | 7.52 | #20 | #2,620 |
| 1939 | BSN | 33 | 2.31 | #71 | #10,742 |
| 1940 | PIT | 35 | 0.72 | #104 | #15,606 |
| 1941 | WS1 | 5 | -3.00 | #309 | #45,239 |
| 1943 | BSN | 10 | -2.88 | #289 | #44,099 |
★ Best season by Z