C · 21 seasons · 1959 – 1980 · B/T: L/R
Few careers score higher: Tim McCarver sits 1st of 0 hitters all-time in roto value, built over 21 seasons. No season of his scores higher than 1967, at +9.7, 33rd that season and 5279th of 111,420 player-seasons on record. His profile is all upside: batting average (+13.4), RBI (+11.3) and runs (+7.7), and nothing on the debit side.
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1959 | STL | 8 | -2.37 | #455 | #93,169 |
| 1960 | STL | 10 | -2.19 | #319 | #75,914 |
| 1961 | STL | 22 | -1.93 | #278 | #49,293 |
| 1963 | STL | 127 | 4.76 | #90 | #14,241 |
| 1964 | STL | 143 | 5.18 | #83 | #13,236 |
| 1965 | STL | 113 | 5.14 | #83 | #13,342 |
| 1966 | STL | 150 | 7.10 | #60 | #9,276 |
| 1967★ | STL | 138 | 9.72 | #33 | #5,279 |
| 1968 | STL | 128 | 3.70 | #101 | #16,994 |
| 1969 | STL | 138 | 3.69 | #132 | #17,028 |
| 1970 | PHI | 44 | 0.22 | #228 | #29,308 |
| 1971 | PHI | 134 | 5.13 | #105 | #13,359 |
| 1972 | MON | 122 | 2.66 | #148 | #19,957 |
| 1973 | STL | 130 | 1.67 | #179 | #23,263 |
| 1974 | STL | 85 | -1.60 | #338 | #43,206 |
| 1975 | PHI | 59 | -1.24 | #307 | #39,159 |
| 1976 | PHI | 90 | 0.97 | #203 | #25,895 |
| 1977 | PHI | 93 | 1.90 | #193 | #22,447 |
| 1978 | PHI | 90 | -0.91 | #308 | #36,261 |
| 1979 | PHI | 79 | -1.49 | #343 | #41,791 |
| 1980 | PHI | 6 | -2.18 | #460 | #75,559 |
★ Best season by Z