P · 9 seasons · 1965 – 1973 · B/T: R/R
Few careers score higher: Jim McGlothlin sits 1st of 0 pitchers all-time in roto value, built over 9 seasons. No season of his scores higher than 1967, at +4.3, 47th that season and 6519th of 51,303 player-seasons on record. Career value accumulated in wins (+3.2), strikeouts (+2.5) and WHIP (+0.3), and drained away in ERA (-1.8).
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1965 | CAL | 3 | -2.36 | #554 | #92,933 |
| 1966 | CAL | 19 | -2.57 | #646 | #101,723 |
| 1967 | CAL | 32 | -2.44 | #615 | #97,295 |
| 1968 | CAL | 40 | -2.85 | #643 | #107,022 |
| 1969 | CAL | 37 | -2.94 | #818 | #108,019 |
| 1970 | CIN | 35 | -2.64 | #773 | #103,612 |
| 1971 | CIN | 30 | -2.52 | #712 | #100,323 |
| 1972★ | CIN | 31 | -2.13 | #435 | #68,195 |
| 1973 | CIN | 29 | -2.49 | #720 | #99,165 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1965 | CAL | 3 | -2.40 | #214 | #37,673 |
| 1966 | CAL | 19 | -2.53 | #229 | #39,535 |
| 1967★ | CAL | 32 | 4.34 | #47 | #6,519 |
| 1968 | CAL | 40 | 0.91 | #93 | #14,969 |
| 1969 | CAL | 37 | 2.23 | #80 | #10,925 |
| 1970 | CIN | 35 | 2.79 | #70 | #9,549 |
| 1971 | CIN | 30 | 1.97 | #81 | #11,685 |
| 1972 | CIN | 31 | -2.10 | #226 | #33,132 |
| 1973 | CIN | 29 | -4.44 | #322 | #50,521 |
★ Best season by Z