P · 15 seasons · 1944 – 1964 · B/T: B/R
Cal McLish is 1st of 0 pitchers in career roto value, a top-tier career by any lens the site offers. His best year was 1958: +6.3 roto value, 19th that season and 3759th of 51,303 player-seasons on record. He banked roto value in wins (+3.1) and gave it back in WHIP (-3.2), ERA (-2.3) and strikeouts (-0.5).
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1944 | BRO | 31 | -1.85 | #437 | #47,558 |
| 1946 | BRO | 1 | -2.00 | #574 | #51,895 |
| 1947 | PIT | 1 | -2.08 | #521 | #62,421 |
| 1948 | PIT | 3 | -2.07 | #560 | #61,885 |
| 1949 | CHC | 9 | -1.95 | #248 | #49,959 |
| 1951 | CHC | 31 | -2.93 | #520 | #107,896 |
| 1956 | CLE | 39 | -2.30 | #363 | #87,613 |
| 1957★ | CLE | 44 | -1.84 | #242 | #47,384 |
| 1958 | CLE | 39 | -3.19 | #571 | #109,806 |
| 1959 | CLE | 35 | -1.97 | #264 | #50,572 |
| 1960 | CIN | 37 | -3.26 | #567 | #110,140 |
| 1961 | CWS | 31 | -2.59 | #546 | #102,429 |
| 1962 | PHI | 32 | -3.20 | #688 | #109,869 |
| 1963 | PHI | 33 | -2.25 | #378 | #82,975 |
| 1964 | PHI | 2 | -2.23 | #434 | #80,189 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1944 | BRO | 23 | -6.91 | #342 | #51,276 |
| 1946 | BRO | 1 | -2.07 | #254 | #32,603 |
| 1947 | PIT | 1 | -2.32 | #260 | #36,473 |
| 1948 | PIT | 2 | -2.57 | #269 | #40,100 |
| 1949 | CHC | 8 | -2.94 | #175 | #44,632 |
| 1951 | CHC | 30 | -1.49 | #113 | #26,576 |
| 1956 | CLE | 37 | -2.34 | #163 | #36,702 |
| 1957 | CLE | 42 | 3.71 | #41 | #7,667 |
| 1958★ | CLE | 39 | 6.34 | #19 | #3,759 |
| 1959 | CLE | 35 | 3.74 | #46 | #7,614 |
| 1960 | CIN | 37 | -2.07 | #139 | #32,645 |
| 1961 | CWS | 31 | 0.28 | #100 | #17,222 |
| 1962 | PHI | 32 | -0.38 | #125 | #20,214 |
| 1963 | PHI | 32 | 3.07 | #58 | #8,915 |
| 1964 | PHI | 2 | -2.38 | #213 | #37,365 |
★ Best season by Z