P · 10 seasons · 1918 – 1927 · B/T: R/R
Hugh McQuillan ranks 1st of 0 pitchers by career roto value, one of the highest totals the site records. His best year was 1924: +8.1 roto value, 17th that season and 2158th of 51,303 player-seasons on record. The value came from wins (+6.4), strikeouts (+4.0) and ERA (+2.2), with no category working against him.
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1918 | BSN | 1 | -2.31 | #448 | #88,256 |
| 1919 | BSN | 20 | -2.20 | #350 | #77,686 |
| 1920★ | BSN | 38 | -1.24 | #269 | #39,192 |
| 1921 | BSN | 45 | -2.25 | #443 | #82,281 |
| 1922 | BSN | 47 | -2.87 | #738 | #107,278 |
| 1923 | NY1 | 41 | -2.63 | #772 | #103,444 |
| 1924 | NY1 | 35 | -2.57 | #740 | #101,875 |
| 1925 | NY1 | 16 | -2.82 | #781 | #106,711 |
| 1926 | NY1 | 34 | -3.03 | #813 | #108,813 |
| 1927 | BSN | 24 | -2.55 | #717 | #101,387 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1918 | BSN | 1 | -1.98 | #149 | #31,370 |
| 1919 | BSN | 16 | -0.85 | #90 | #22,515 |
| 1920 | BSN | 38 | 5.57 | #32 | #4,655 |
| 1921 | BSN | 45 | 5.53 | #35 | #4,705 |
| 1922 | BSN | 43 | 1.15 | #87 | #14,135 |
| 1923 | NY1 | 38 | 5.84 | #37 | #4,317 |
| 1924★ | NY1 | 27 | 8.13 | #17 | #2,158 |
| 1925 | NY1 | 14 | -1.98 | #200 | #31,361 |
| 1926 | NY1 | 33 | 2.91 | #65 | #9,266 |
| 1927 | BSN | 24 | -2.53 | #263 | #39,499 |
★ Best season by Z