P · 14 seasons · 1901 – 1914 · B/T: R/R
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1901 | CLE | 31 | -3.30 | #367 | #110,226 |
| 1902 | CLE | 36 | -2.54 | #220 | #100,864 |
| 1903 | CLE | 29 | -3.64 | #401 | #111,040 |
| 1904 | CLE | 26 | -3.40 | #368 | #110,527 |
| 1905 | CLE | 31 | -3.58 | #445 | #110,960 |
| 1906 | CLE | 5 | -2.77 | #452 | #105,989 |
| 1907 | NYY | 15 | -2.46 | #302 | #97,885 |
| 1908 | PHI | 3 | -2.45 | #322 | #97,454 |
| 1909 | PHI | 38 | -3.60 | #596 | #110,994 |
| 1910★ | PHI | 46 | -1.96 | #308 | #50,067 |
| 1911 | PHI | 42 | -3.53 | #679 | #110,804 |
| 1912 | PHI | 31 | -3.01 | #696 | #108,609 |
| 1913 | PHI | 19 | -2.67 | #656 | #104,148 |
| 1914 | BUF | 36 | -2.64 | #732 | #103,453 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1901 | CLE | 31 | 2.50 | #33 | #10,229 |
| 1902 | CLE | 36 | 3.54 | #25 | #7,993 |
| 1903★ | CLE | 29 | 7.36 | #9 | #2,757 |
| 1904 | CLE | 26 | 2.54 | #34 | #10,119 |
| 1905 | CLE | 31 | 2.08 | #35 | #11,333 |
| 1906 | CLE | 5 | -2.84 | #159 | #43,519 |
| 1907 | NYY | 15 | -2.99 | #152 | #45,018 |
| 1908 | PHI | 3 | -1.01 | #84 | #23,459 |
| 1909 | PHI | 38 | 6.05 | #24 | #4,066 |
| 1910 | PHI | 46 | 5.68 | #20 | #4,514 |
| 1911 | PHI | 42 | 6.01 | #22 | #4,116 |
| 1912 | PHI | 31 | 0.30 | #75 | #17,132 |
| 1913 | PHI | 19 | -3.13 | #246 | #46,094 |
| 1914 | BUF | 36 | -1.73 | #152 | #28,555 |
★ Best season by Z