P · 9 seasons · 1901 – 1909 · B/T: L/R
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1901 | PHI | 41 | -1.17 | #145 | #38,523 |
| 1902 | WS1 | 56 | -1.22 | #157 | #38,963 |
| 1903 | WS1 | 55 | -0.79 | #136 | #35,315 |
| 1904 | WS1 | 55 | -1.33 | #164 | #39,997 |
| 1905 | NYY | 55 | -1.82 | #198 | #46,764 |
| 1906 | NYY | 47 | 0.07 | #150 | #30,039 |
| 1907★ | NYY | 44 | 0.36 | #136 | #28,623 |
| 1908 | NYY | 38 | -1.77 | #235 | #45,967 |
| 1909 | NYY | 22 | -1.72 | #263 | #45,154 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1901★ | PHI | 35 | 9.44 | #4 | #1,401 |
| 1902 | WS1 | 38 | 0.70 | #46 | #15,659 |
| 1903 | WS1 | 36 | -0.33 | #56 | #19,929 |
| 1904 | NYY | 30 | -0.76 | #65 | #22,017 |
| 1905 | NYY | 40 | 3.09 | #30 | #8,857 |
| 1906 | NYY | 45 | 6.05 | #18 | #4,073 |
| 1907 | NYY | 36 | 0.63 | #59 | #15,908 |
| 1908 | NYY | 21 | -3.24 | #189 | #46,836 |
| 1909 | NYY | 1 | -2.64 | #188 | #41,088 |
★ Best season by Z