P · 10 seasons · 1958 – 1967 · B/T: B/L
Jim O'Toole is 1st of 0 pitchers in career roto value, a top-tier career by any lens the site offers. 1961 was the high-water mark, worth +8.4, 8th that season and 1994th of 51,303 player-seasons on record. His profile is all upside: strikeouts (+8.4), wins (+8.1) and ERA (+2.5), and nothing on the debit side.
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1958★ | CIN | 1 | -2.32 | #410 | #89,322 |
| 1959 | CIN | 29 | -2.48 | #491 | #98,952 |
| 1960 | CIN | 34 | -3.33 | #569 | #110,397 |
| 1961 | CIN | 39 | -2.74 | #570 | #105,421 |
| 1962 | CIN | 36 | -3.51 | #696 | #110,955 |
| 1963 | CIN | 33 | -2.65 | #618 | #103,859 |
| 1964 | CIN | 30 | -3.20 | #683 | #109,872 |
| 1965 | CIN | 29 | -2.95 | #670 | #108,085 |
| 1966 | CIN | 25 | -2.78 | #680 | #106,107 |
| 1967 | CWS | 15 | -2.39 | #594 | #94,388 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1958 | CIN | 1 | -2.23 | #150 | #35,084 |
| 1959 | CIN | 28 | -4.14 | #238 | #50,101 |
| 1960 | CIN | 34 | 2.48 | #56 | #10,304 |
| 1961★ | CIN | 39 | 8.39 | #8 | #1,994 |
| 1962 | CIN | 36 | 6.37 | #23 | #3,727 |
| 1963 | CIN | 33 | 5.82 | #26 | #4,339 |
| 1964 | CIN | 30 | 6.73 | #24 | #3,329 |
| 1965 | CIN | 29 | -5.45 | #298 | #51,120 |
| 1966 | CIN | 25 | -0.40 | #127 | #20,285 |
| 1967 | CWS | 15 | -1.04 | #153 | #23,622 |
★ Best season by Z