P · 8 seasons · 1912 – 1919 · B/T: L/L
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1912 | CIN | 1 | -2.08 | #406 | #62,512 |
| 1913 | CIN | 43 | -2.23 | #559 | #80,132 |
| 1914★ | KCF | 45 | -0.99 | #298 | #36,903 |
| 1915 | KCF | 44 | -1.58 | #347 | #42,936 |
| 1916 | CHC | 44 | -2.61 | #581 | #102,876 |
| 1917 | STL | 38 | -1.98 | #294 | #51,303 |
| 1918 | STL | 36 | -2.51 | #534 | #99,748 |
| 1919 | PHI | 27 | -2.33 | #404 | #90,758 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1912 | CIN | 1 | -1.66 | #131 | #27,909 |
| 1913 | CIN | 39 | -0.50 | #98 | #20,733 |
| 1914★ | KCF | 42 | 7.62 | #18 | #2,531 |
| 1915 | KCF | 42 | 5.71 | #33 | #4,475 |
| 1916 | CHC | 37 | 3.32 | #42 | #8,399 |
| 1917 | STL | 36 | 2.65 | #44 | #9,849 |
| 1918 | STL | 30 | 2.78 | #46 | #9,538 |
| 1919 | PHI | 21 | -2.08 | #146 | #32,736 |
★ Best season by Z