P · 13 seasons · 1942 – 1954 · B/T: R/R
Few careers score higher: Allie Reynolds sits 1st of 0 pitchers all-time in roto value, built over 13 seasons. No season of his scores higher than 1952, at +13.0, 3rd that season and 389th of 51,303 player-seasons on record. His profile is all upside: strikeouts (+25.3), wins (+22.0) and ERA (+13.9), and nothing on the debit side.
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1942 | CLE | 2 | -2.21 | #579 | #78,356 |
| 1943 | CLE | 39 | -2.58 | #794 | #102,210 |
| 1944 | CLE | 41 | -2.87 | #831 | #107,265 |
| 1945 | CLE | 44 | -3.91 | #868 | #111,341 |
| 1946 | CLE | 35 | -1.80 | #469 | #46,459 |
| 1947 | NYY | 38 | -2.94 | #832 | #108,062 |
| 1948★ | NYY | 41 | -1.70 | #367 | #44,821 |
| 1949 | NYY | 37 | -2.13 | #272 | #69,335 |
| 1950 | NYY | 36 | -2.63 | #466 | #103,202 |
| 1951 | NYY | 43 | -2.09 | #272 | #63,337 |
| 1952 | NYY | 41 | -2.82 | #524 | #106,626 |
| 1953 | NYY | 42 | -2.77 | #496 | #105,911 |
| 1954 | NYY | 36 | -2.58 | #471 | #102,105 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1942 | CLE | 2 | -2.29 | #214 | #35,899 |
| 1943 | CLE | 34 | 8.07 | #16 | #2,189 |
| 1944 | CLE | 28 | 2.49 | #66 | #10,264 |
| 1945 | CLE | 44 | 7.88 | #23 | #2,345 |
| 1946 | CLE | 31 | 0.43 | #123 | #16,680 |
| 1947 | NYY | 34 | 8.97 | #15 | #1,639 |
| 1948 | NYY | 39 | 5.54 | #31 | #4,693 |
| 1949 | NYY | 35 | 3.15 | #44 | #8,761 |
| 1950 | NYY | 35 | 6.28 | #19 | #3,835 |
| 1951 | NYY | 40 | 10.48 | #5 | #943 |
| 1952★ | NYY | 35 | 12.96 | #3 | #389 |
| 1953 | NYY | 41 | 6.75 | #14 | #3,318 |
| 1954 | NYY | 36 | 5.92 | #20 | #4,212 |
★ Best season by Z