P · 10 seasons · 1939 – 1949 · B/T: R/R
Elmer Riddle ranks 1st of 0 pitchers by career roto value, one of the highest totals the site records. No season of his scores higher than 1941, at +11.6, 7th that season and 622nd of 51,303 player-seasons on record. His profile is all upside: wins (+4.4), ERA (+4.0) and strikeouts (+0.6), and nothing on the debit side.
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1939 | CIN | 1 | -2.13 | #520 | #69,487 |
| 1940 | CIN | 15 | -2.23 | #650 | #80,332 |
| 1941★ | CIN | 33 | -1.65 | #362 | #44,070 |
| 1942 | CIN | 29 | -1.71 | #358 | #44,886 |
| 1943 | CIN | 36 | -2.22 | #681 | #79,540 |
| 1944 | CIN | 4 | -2.08 | #652 | #62,401 |
| 1945 | CIN | 12 | -1.98 | #496 | #51,310 |
| 1947 | CIN | 16 | -2.17 | #644 | #74,289 |
| 1948 | PIT | 29 | -1.71 | #370 | #44,962 |
| 1949 | PIT | 16 | -2.60 | #453 | #102,596 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1939 | CIN | 1 | -1.96 | #205 | #31,086 |
| 1940 | CIN | 15 | 0.14 | #119 | #17,841 |
| 1941★ | CIN | 33 | 11.64 | #7 | #622 |
| 1942 | CIN | 29 | 0.04 | #121 | #18,272 |
| 1943 | CIN | 36 | 8.32 | #15 | #2,027 |
| 1944 | CIN | 4 | -1.69 | #181 | #28,224 |
| 1945 | CIN | 12 | -4.60 | #354 | #50,686 |
| 1947 | CIN | 16 | -4.87 | #356 | #50,891 |
| 1948 | PIT | 28 | 4.19 | #45 | #6,785 |
| 1949 | PIT | 16 | -2.84 | #167 | #43,597 |
★ Best season by Z