P · 19 seasons · 2001 – 2019 · B/T: L/L
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2001 | CLE | 33 | -2.26 | #1,052 | #83,747 |
| 2002 | CLE | 33 | -2.19 | #939 | #76,918 |
| 2003 | CLE | 31 | -1.91 | #492 | #48,738 |
| 2004 | CLE | 30 | -2.13 | #871 | #68,786 |
| 2005 | CLE | 31 | -1.74 | #459 | #45,367 |
| 2006 | CLE | 28 | -2.07 | #570 | #61,784 |
| 2007 | CLE | 34 | -1.92 | #518 | #49,035 |
| 2008★ | CLE | 35 | -1.61 | #464 | #43,412 |
| 2009 | NYY | 34 | -2.03 | #536 | #55,438 |
| 2010 | NYY | 34 | -2.16 | #980 | #73,276 |
| 2011 | NYY | 33 | -2.21 | #1,098 | #78,399 |
| 2012 | NYY | 28 | -2.29 | #1,138 | #86,978 |
| 2013 | NYY | 32 | -2.19 | #1,093 | #76,877 |
| 2014 | NYY | 8 | -2.13 | #1,062 | #69,408 |
| 2015 | NYY | 29 | -2.16 | #1,132 | #73,387 |
| 2016 | NYY | 30 | -2.06 | #989 | #58,502 |
| 2017 | NYY | 27 | -2.18 | #1,139 | #74,847 |
| 2018 | NYY | 29 | -2.08 | #600 | #61,934 |
| 2019 | NYY | 23 | -2.17 | #1,212 | #74,610 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2001 | CLE | 33 | 5.08 | #57 | #5,346 |
| 2002 | CLE | 33 | 3.60 | #89 | #7,871 |
| 2003 | CLE | 30 | 5.99 | #47 | #4,138 |
| 2004 | CLE | 30 | 4.67 | #68 | #5,972 |
| 2005 | CLE | 31 | 6.10 | #50 | #4,024 |
| 2006 | CLE | 28 | 9.49 | #17 | #1,366 |
| 2007 | CLE | 34 | 13.52 | #2 | #307 |
| 2008★ | MIL | 35 | 15.09 | #2 | #175 |
| 2009 | NYY | 34 | 11.96 | #10 | #548 |
| 2010 | NYY | 34 | 10.75 | #7 | #863 |
| 2011 | NYY | 33 | 10.36 | #11 | #986 |
| 2012 | NYY | 28 | 8.73 | #22 | #1,775 |
| 2013 | NYY | 32 | 1.36 | #179 | #13,453 |
| 2014 | NYY | 8 | -1.94 | #436 | #30,851 |
| 2015 | NYY | 29 | -0.90 | #333 | #22,779 |
| 2016 | NYY | 30 | 3.66 | #105 | #7,749 |
| 2017 | NYY | 27 | 5.54 | #66 | #4,684 |
| 2018 | NYY | 29 | 3.75 | #113 | #7,576 |
| 2019 | NYY | 23 | 0.23 | #272 | #17,426 |
★ Best season by Z