P · 11 seasons · 1943 – 1954 · B/T: R/R
Carl Scheib ranks 1st of 0 pitchers by career roto value, one of the highest totals the site records. His best year was 1951: +2.6 roto value, 50th that season and 9887th of 51,303 player-seasons on record. He banked roto value in saves (+1.9) and gave it back in ERA (-8.2), WHIP (-4.4) and strikeouts (-3.5).
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1943 | PHA | 6 | -2.25 | #693 | #82,918 |
| 1944 | PHA | 15 | -1.89 | #460 | #48,281 |
| 1945 | PHA | 4 | -2.12 | #632 | #67,065 |
| 1947 | PHA | 22 | -2.55 | #789 | #101,257 |
| 1948★ | PHA | 52 | 0.20 | #212 | #29,414 |
| 1949 | PHA | 47 | -1.91 | #244 | #49,004 |
| 1950 | PHA | 50 | -1.92 | #235 | #49,155 |
| 1951 | PHA | 48 | -0.60 | #166 | #34,043 |
| 1952 | PHA | 44 | -1.90 | #249 | #48,684 |
| 1953 | PHA | 35 | -2.33 | #377 | #90,919 |
| 1954 | STL | 4 | -2.31 | #375 | #88,846 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1943 | PHA | 6 | -2.47 | #241 | #38,671 |
| 1944 | PHA | 15 | -1.79 | #190 | #29,138 |
| 1945 | PHA | 4 | -1.90 | #219 | #30,402 |
| 1947 | PHA | 21 | -2.53 | #284 | #39,511 |
| 1948 | PHA | 32 | 1.77 | #90 | #12,258 |
| 1949 | PHA | 38 | -3.32 | #193 | #47,473 |
| 1950 | PHA | 43 | -4.49 | #228 | #50,572 |
| 1951★ | PHA | 46 | 2.65 | #50 | #9,887 |
| 1952 | PHA | 30 | 0.77 | #73 | #15,449 |
| 1953 | PHA | 28 | -1.10 | #109 | #23,995 |
| 1954 | STL | 4 | -3.33 | #199 | #47,529 |
★ Best season by Z