P · 12 seasons · 1934 – 1945 · B/T: L/L
Al Smith is 1st of 0 pitchers in career roto value, a top-tier career by any lens the site offers. His best year was 1943: +7.0 roto value, 29th that season and 3128th of 51,303 player-seasons on record. The value came from wins (+8.8), strikeouts (+5.8) and ERA (+3.7), with no category working against him.
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1934 | NY1 | 30 | -2.10 | #418 | #63,891 |
| 1935 | NY1 | 40 | -2.59 | #599 | #102,374 |
| 1936 | NY1 | 43 | -2.77 | #632 | #105,970 |
| 1937 | NY1 | 33 | -2.49 | #771 | #99,120 |
| 1938 | PHI | 37 | -2.78 | #798 | #106,076 |
| 1939 | PHI | 5 | -2.20 | #602 | #78,028 |
| 1940★ | CLE | 31 | -1.17 | #287 | #38,561 |
| 1941 | CLE | 30 | -2.38 | #718 | #93,598 |
| 1942 | CLE | 30 | -1.77 | #373 | #46,024 |
| 1943 | CLE | 30 | -2.15 | #613 | #71,748 |
| 1944 | CLE | 28 | -2.49 | #807 | #99,135 |
| 1945 | CLE | 22 | -1.67 | #387 | #44,329 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1934 | NY1 | 30 | 2.46 | #59 | #10,334 |
| 1935 | NY1 | 40 | 6.07 | #25 | #4,050 |
| 1936 | NY1 | 43 | 6.24 | #26 | #3,876 |
| 1937 | NY1 | 33 | 0.20 | #110 | #17,558 |
| 1938 | PHI | 37 | -2.94 | #321 | #44,635 |
| 1939 | PHI | 5 | -2.18 | #232 | #34,297 |
| 1940 | CLE | 31 | 5.32 | #38 | #5,008 |
| 1941 | CLE | 29 | 3.16 | #57 | #8,737 |
| 1942 | CLE | 30 | 0.67 | #108 | #15,799 |
| 1943★ | CLE | 29 | 6.98 | #29 | #3,128 |
| 1944 | CLE | 28 | -0.26 | #112 | #19,616 |
| 1945 | CLE | 21 | 0.08 | #119 | #18,068 |
★ Best season by Z