C · 12 seasons · 1919 – 1930 · B/T: L/R
Few careers score higher: Earl Smith sits 1st of 0 hitters all-time in roto value, built over 12 seasons. No season of his scores higher than 1921, at +5.2, 84th that season and 13271st of 111,420 player-seasons on record. On the credit side, home runs (+6.5), RBI (+5.4) and batting average (+5.0). On the debit side, stolen bases (-3.2).
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1919 | NY1 | 21 | -1.62 | #257 | #43,583 |
| 1920 | NY1 | 91 | 1.67 | #141 | #23,290 |
| 1921★ | NY1 | 89 | 5.17 | #84 | #13,271 |
| 1922 | NY1 | 90 | 2.31 | #145 | #21,081 |
| 1923 | BSN | 96 | 0.27 | #232 | #29,069 |
| 1924 | PIT | 72 | 1.80 | #180 | #22,809 |
| 1925 | PIT | 109 | 4.56 | #115 | #14,770 |
| 1926 | PIT | 105 | 3.44 | #138 | #17,745 |
| 1927 | PIT | 66 | 0.01 | #243 | #30,400 |
| 1928 | PIT | 56 | -1.50 | #332 | #41,912 |
| 1929 | STL | 57 | -0.40 | #242 | #32,766 |
| 1930 | STL | 8 | -2.68 | #674 | #104,378 |
★ Best season by Z