Charlie Sullivan

One category carried Charlie Sullivan and the rest pulled him back: +1.9 from saves, against a career total of -5.6. His best year was 1930: -0.2 roto value, 118th that season and 19192nd of 51,303 player-seasons on record. He banked roto value in saves (+1.9) and gave it back in WHIP (-2.3), ERA (-2.2) and strikeouts (-1.1).