P · 17 seasons · 1919 – 1936 · B/T: R/R
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1919 | CLE | 26 | -1.54 | #247 | #42,348 |
| 1920 | CLE | 27 | -1.49 | #297 | #41,734 |
| 1921 | CLE | 48 | -1.09 | #269 | #37,785 |
| 1922 | CLE | 56 | -1.12 | #289 | #38,054 |
| 1923★ | CLE | 58 | 0.90 | #209 | #26,200 |
| 1924 | CLE | 59 | -0.68 | #303 | #34,545 |
| 1925 | CLE | 55 | -1.69 | #370 | #44,579 |
| 1926 | CLE | 50 | -1.51 | #350 | #41,990 |
| 1927 | CLE | 43 | -1.86 | #384 | #47,749 |
| 1928 | CLE | 55 | -1.11 | #304 | #38,006 |
| 1929 | DET | 40 | -0.81 | #264 | #35,477 |
| 1930 | DET | 59 | -0.81 | #256 | #35,492 |
| 1931 | DET | 53 | -1.48 | #286 | #41,653 |
| 1932 | DET | 38 | -2.48 | #811 | #98,754 |
| 1933 | NYY | 21 | -2.01 | #346 | #52,663 |
| 1934 | NYY | 10 | -1.89 | #335 | #48,465 |
| 1936 | CLE | 24 | -1.67 | #286 | #44,353 |
★ Best season by Z
| Season ↑ | Tm | G | Z | Szn | All-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1919 | CLE | 26 | 0.57 | #66 | #16,124 |
| 1920 | CLE | 27 | -2.00 | #173 | #31,573 |
| 1921 | CLE | 41 | 2.98 | #56 | #9,107 |
| 1922 | CLE | 50 | 6.54 | #27 | #3,538 |
| 1923 | CLE | 54 | 11.75 | #5 | #585 |
| 1924 | CLE | 28 | -0.75 | #143 | #21,956 |
| 1925 | CLE | 29 | 3.58 | #55 | #7,903 |
| 1926★ | CLE | 39 | 13.31 | #3 | #331 |
| 1927 | CLE | 25 | 0.23 | #111 | #17,410 |
| 1928 | CLE | 31 | 2.89 | #63 | #9,307 |
| 1929 | DET | 32 | 5.66 | #33 | #4,528 |
| 1930 | DET | 33 | 8.83 | #9 | #1,718 |
| 1931 | DET | 29 | 5.30 | #27 | #5,034 |
| 1932 | DET | 33 | 4.02 | #47 | #7,072 |
| 1933 | NYY | 19 | -1.69 | #142 | #28,127 |
| 1934 | NYY | 10 | -2.95 | #250 | #44,623 |
| 1936 | CLE | 7 | -3.13 | #254 | #46,070 |
★ Best season by Z