Head-to-Head

Two careers, on ½PPR fantasy points. Pick any two players and compare their seasons, arcs, and where each ranks all-time.

Player A

Tom Brady

Player B

Peyton Manning

Tom Brady

Peyton Manning

5943	Career Pts (½PPR)	4677
258.4	Avg / Season	275.1
390.0	Best Season	410.0
23	Seasons	17

Tom BradyPeyton Manning

#	Player	Season	Pos	Stat Line	Pts	Szn Rank	All-Time
1	Peyton Manning	2013	QB	5,477 Yds · 55 TD · 10 INT · -31 RushYd · 1 RushTD	410.0	#1	#8
2	Tom Brady	2007	QB	4,806 Yds · 50 TD · 8 INT · 98 RushYd · 2 RushTD	390.0	#1	#18
3	Tom Brady	2021	QB	5,316 Yds · 43 TD · 12 INT · 81 RushYd · 2 RushTD	374.7	#3	#29
4	Tom Brady	2011	QB	5,235 Yds · 39 TD · 12 INT · 109 RushYd · 3 RushTD	366.3	#4	#42
5	Peyton Manning	2004	QB	4,557 Yds · 49 TD · 10 INT · 38 RushYd · 0 RushTD	360.1	#2	#49
6	Tom Brady	2015	QB	4,770 Yds · 36 TD · 7 INT · 53 RushYd · 3 RushTD	344.2	#2	#78
7	Tom Brady	2012	QB	4,827 Yds · 34 TD · 8 INT · 32 RushYd · 4 RushTD	340.3	#3	#93
8	Tom Brady	2020	QB	4,633 Yds · 40 TD · 12 INT · 6 RushYd · 3 RushTD	337.9	#8	#101
9	Peyton Manning	2014	QB	4,727 Yds · 39 TD · 15 INT · -24 RushYd · 0 RushTD	312.7	#7	#170
10	Peyton Manning	2012	QB	4,659 Yds · 37 TD · 11 INT · 6 RushYd · 0 RushTD	311.0	#7	#179
11	Peyton Manning	2006	QB	4,397 Yds · 31 TD · 9 INT · 36 RushYd · 4 RushTD	309.5	#4	#186
12	Tom Brady	2010	QB	3,900 Yds · 36 TD · 4 INT · 30 RushYd · 1 RushTD	299.0	#4	#244
13	Tom Brady	2017	QB	4,577 Yds · 32 TD · 8 INT · 28 RushYd · 0 RushTD	295.9	#5	#260
14	Peyton Manning	2000	QB	4,413 Yds · 33 TD · 15 INT · 116 RushYd · 1 RushTD	294.1	#7	#268
15	Peyton Manning	2010	QB	4,700 Yds · 33 TD · 17 INT · 18 RushYd · 0 RushTD	285.8	#5	#319
16	Tom Brady	2018	QB	4,355 Yds · 29 TD · 11 INT · 35 RushYd · 2 RushTD	280.8	#20	#368
17	Peyton Manning	2009	QB	4,500 Yds · 33 TD · 16 INT · -13 RushYd · 0 RushTD	278.7	#9	#390
18	Tom Brady	2014	QB	4,109 Yds · 33 TD · 9 INT · 57 RushYd · 0 RushTD	278.1	#16	#396
19	Peyton Manning	2007	QB	4,040 Yds · 31 TD · 14 INT · -5 RushYd · 3 RushTD	275.1	#6	#422
20	Tom Brady	2022	QB	4,694 Yds · 25 TD · 9 INT · -1 RushYd · 1 RushTD	271.7	#19	#456
21	Tom Brady	2009	QB	4,398 Yds · 28 TD · 13 INT · 44 RushYd · 1 RushTD	270.3	#11	#471
22	Peyton Manning	2003	QB	4,267 Yds · 29 TD · 10 INT · 29 RushYd · 0 RushTD	269.9	#11	#473
23	Peyton Manning	2002	QB	4,200 Yds · 27 TD · 19 INT · 148 RushYd · 2 RushTD	264.8	#15	#520
24	Tom Brady	2019	QB	4,057 Yds · 24 TD · 8 INT · 34 RushYd · 3 RushTD	263.7	#18	#531
25	Peyton Manning	2001	QB	4,131 Yds · 26 TD · 23 INT · 157 RushYd · 4 RushTD	260.9	#13	#560
26	Tom Brady	2016	QB	3,554 Yds · 28 TD · 2 INT · 64 RushYd · 0 RushTD	258.6	#20	#593
27	Peyton Manning	1999	QB	4,135 Yds · 26 TD · 15 INT · 73 RushYd · 2 RushTD	254.7	#11	#650
28	Peyton Manning	2008	QB	4,002 Yds · 27 TD · 12 INT · 21 RushYd · 1 RushTD	254.2	#12	#659
29	Tom Brady	2013	QB	4,343 Yds · 25 TD · 11 INT · 18 RushYd · 0 RushTD	251.5	#26	#691
30	Tom Brady	2005	QB	4,110 Yds · 26 TD · 14 INT · 89 RushYd · 1 RushTD	249.3	#11	#723
31	Tom Brady	2002	QB	3,764 Yds · 28 TD · 14 INT · 110 RushYd · 1 RushTD	245.6	#22	#764
32	Peyton Manning	2005	QB	3,747 Yds · 28 TD · 10 INT · 45 RushYd · 0 RushTD	242.4	#13	#807
33	Tom Brady	2004	QB	3,690 Yds · 28 TD · 14 INT · 28 RushYd · 0 RushTD	224.4	#29	#1,117
34	Tom Brady	2006	QB	3,533 Yds · 24 TD · 12 INT · 102 RushYd · 0 RushTD	219.5	#22	#1,229
35	Tom Brady	2003	QB	3,620 Yds · 23 TD · 12 INT · 63 RushYd · 1 RushTD	215.1	#32	#1,338
36	Peyton Manning	1998	QB	3,739 Yds · 26 TD · 28 INT · 62 RushYd · 0 RushTD	201.8	#32	#1,700
37	Tom Brady	2001	QB	2,843 Yds · 18 TD · 12 INT · 43 RushYd · 0 RushTD	162.8	#70	#3,093
38	Peyton Manning	2015	QB	2,249 Yds · 9 TD · 17 INT · -6 RushYd · 0 RushTD	91.4	#168	#7,558
39	Tom Brady	2008	QB	76 Yds · 0 TD · 0 INT · 0 RushYd · 0 RushTD	3.0	#456	#23,355
40	Tom Brady	2000	QB	6 Yds · 0 TD · 0 INT · 0 RushYd · 0 RushTD	0.2	#472	#25,600

Their seasons, ranked head-to-head (½PPR points)