Indianapolis Colts
3 roto titles · 57 seasons (1970–2026) · BAL → IND
Across 57 seasons, the Indianapolis Colts have been Roto Champ three times, last in 2006. The first arrived in 1976, and then the franchise waited 28 seasons for the next one, so this is really two separate eras rather than one long run. Their average finish is 14.1 all time, against 17.3 over the last ten seasons, a step down from the franchise norm.
The best single roto season in franchise history belongs to Edgerrin James in 1999, worth a 4.0 z-score. Marvin Harrison is the franchise’s most persistent roto presence, owning 8 of its 50 best seasons. One quirk worth knowing: the All-Franchise Team below fills strict positions, so Curtis Dickey, Randy McMillan and Eric Dickerson all rate above somebody who made it and still missed, purely because their position ran out.
Roto championships
Roto finish by season
Where Indianapolis Colts placed in each season’s Roto Champ standings (1st at the top). Gold dots are championship seasons; hover a point for detail.
Season by season
Where they finished each year, with a link to that season’s best-lineup roster (QB · RB · RB · WR · WR · WR · TE · FLEX by ½PPR points).
| Season | Finish | Roster |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 23rd of 32live | View roster → |
| 2025 | 8th of 32 | View roster → |
| 2024 | 23rd of 32 | View roster → |
| 2023 | 18th of 32 | View roster → |
| 2022 | 28th of 32 | View roster → |
| 2021 | 11th of 32 | View roster → |
| 2020 | 18th of 32 | View roster → |
| 2019 | 26th of 32 | View roster → |
All-Franchise Team
Indianapolis Colts’ all-time First, Second, and Third teams, a full skill lineup by ½PPR fantasy points.
🏆 First Team
Second Team
Third Team
Who just missed
- RBCurtis Dickeyposition full5 seasons763.5
- RBRandy McMillanposition full6 seasons761.2
- RBEric Dickersonposition full4 seasons755.7
- RBAlbert Bentleyposition full7 seasons735.2
- RBDominic Rhodesposition full7 seasons628.4
- QBJim Harbaughposition full4 seasons575.4
- RBJoe Washingtonposition full3 seasons566.5
- TEJack Doyleposition full9 seasons556.4
- RBFrank Goreposition full3 seasons530.7
- WRJessie Hester4 seasons524.3
Closest to making it, by ½PPR points. Position full: rated above someone who did make a team, but every slot at their position was already taken.
Best roto seasons
The franchise’s top individual player-seasons by z-score, all-time (each measured against his own position that year).
| # | Player | Season | Z |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | IND1999 | 4.0 | |
1,553Rush Yds13Rush TD62Rec586Rec Yds | |||
| 2 | IND2021 | 4.0 | |
1,811Rush Yds18Rush TD40Rec360Rec Yds | |||
| 3 | IND2000 | 3.5 | |
1,709Rush Yds13Rush TD63Rec594Rec Yds | |||
| 4 | IND1998 | 3.4 | |
1,319Rush Yds6Rush TD86Rec908Rec Yds | |||
| 5 | IND2002 | 3.4 | |
143Rec1,722Rec Yds11Rec TD | |||
| 6 | IND1988 | 3.4 | |
1,659Rush Yds14Rush TD36Rec377Rec Yds | |||
| 7 | IND2009 | 3.3 | |
100Rec1,106Rec Yds10Rec TD | |||
| 8 | BAL1975 | 3.3 | |
1,193Rush Yds11Rush TD60Rec544Rec Yds | |||
| 9 | IND2018 | 3.2 | |
66Rec750Rec Yds13Rec TD | |||
| 10 | IND2025 | 3.2 | |
1,585Rush Yds18Rush TD46Rec378Rec Yds | |||
| 11 | IND2001 | 3.2 | |
109Rec1,524Rec Yds15Rec TD | |||
| 12 | IND1999 | 3.1 | |
115Rec1,663Rec Yds12Rec TD | |||
